MILNET: Guest Briefing Ryan Mauro's Geo-Political Analysis |
In our
opinion, the most interesting development this month, in the War on
Terrorism,
was new intelligence indicating that Osama bin Laden had relinquished
day-to-day control of jihadi operations, while still remaining the
jihadi
movement’s spiritual figurehead and main moneyman. Ayman al-Zawahiri
appears to
be maintaining liaisons with local groups and sectors of certain
intelligence
services, and setting the general technical planning (and likely
authorizing
certain attacks and distributing responsibility).
It also appears that
Al-Qaeda has given Abu Musab al-Zarqawi
control over the Iraqi conflict, and freedom to utilize the network
based in
Western Europe. Seif al-Adel, Saad bin Laden, and others, located in
Iran,
appear to be serving a logistical purpose and maintaining the Gulf
network.
This thinking seems to be confirmed
by an intercepted message sent by bin Laden to Zarqawi urging him to
execute
attacks on US soil. According to one of Zarqawi’s top aides, Zarqawi
discussed,
within his inner circle, the possibility of bombing schools,
restaurants and
movie theaters inside the US. Operatives would acquire visas to
Honduras,
proceed into Mexico, and bribe their way into the US. The aide claims
Zarqawi
stopped putting energy into these plans due to a lack of operatives
willing and
capable of carrying out the mission.[i]
Progress is being made in Iraq that
cannot be ignored. 58 Americans were killed in February, which is quite
a high
number, but we must remember it’s the fewest number of troops killed in
a
month, since July 2004, when 54 were killed. This number is less than
half of
the high point in November 2004.[ii]
The latest WMD report criticizes
American intelligence, as it should. But there’s a major point made in
the
report that the mainstream media isn’t covering. It states that the
Iraqi
National Congress and Ahmed Chalabi had a “negligble impact” on
American WMD
intelligence, and that they provided only two defectors. It also
confirmed that
the INC was not connected to the defector “Curveball”, and there’s no
evidence
that Chalabi, the INC, or anyone else directed him to lie.
It should also be mentioned that two
key American supporters of Chalabi have had obstruction-of-justice
charges
dismissed. Francis Brooke and Margaret Bartel were accused by Zuhair
al-Maliky,
an unqualified judge appointed by Paul Bremer.[iii]
This surely does give ammunition to those that say the war against
Chalabi by
the State Department and Coalition Provincial Authority was politically
motivated.
There was also new evidence released
that Iraq was tied to Al-Qaeda. Documents obtained by the Associated
Press show
that a detainee at Guantanomo Bay is a former Iraqi soldier, who was
ALSO a
member of the Taliban, AND a “trusted agent” of Osama bin Laden. In
August
1998, he traveled to Pakistan alongside an Iraqi intelligence agent,
where he
planned to attack foreign embassies, including the US embassy, with
chemical
mortars.[iv]
In other venues, anthrax was
confirmed to be present in two Pentagon mail facilities. It is the same
genetic
strain as that found in 2001.[v]
Why isn’t this getting more media attention?
Middle East
The United Nations is in its worst
crisis of the last fifty years. The UN-sponsored Oil-For-Food Report
was
issued, and it criticized Kofi Annan for not noticing widespread
corruption,
not the least of which is his son’s shady dealings. Perhaps a second
investigation should be launched into bribery of inspectors and the
personal
agendas of certain staff, such as El-Baradei of the IAEA.
Recently a new case of
bribery was revealed. Tariq Aziz
offered $2 million to the UN’s chief weapons inspector from 1991 to
1997, Rolf
Ekeus, to slant his reporting on Iraqi weapons of mass destruction.
Ekeus, who
reported the story, claims he did not take the bribe.[vi]
In a development not covered by
cable news, the New York Times published a report basically claiming
there were
weapons of mass destruction-related equipment and facilities before the
war
began. The Iraqi government believes looters systematically dismantled
tons of
machinery from the 90 important weapons sites – as confirmed by a UN
report –
and took items including high-precision equipment used to make nuclear
components. Equipment capable of producing chemical, biological or
nuclear
weapons was missing from 8-10 sites. Some material appears to have been
transported to other countries, as chemical weapons equipment has been
seized
in Jordan.[vii]
Although the situation in Iraq is
not satisfactory, it does seem the insurgency is faltering. According
to some
reports, Baathist insurgents want to negotiate and participate in the
fledgling
democracy, if given a chance. The Iraqi people, and even the Baathists,
are
turning on the foreign insurgents. After a deadly suicide bombing
killed 125 in
Hilla, and the relatives of the Jordanian responsible, celebrated him
as a
“martyr”, thousands of Shiites came out and protested against terrorism.[viii]
According to polls, opinion among
Iraqis regarding the situation there has reached a new high. 62% feel
conditions are headed in the right direction, while only 23% hold the
opposite
view. 48% favor a “special role” for religion in government, while 44%
think
religion and government should be totally separate. Only 4% of the
Iraqis feel
that Sharia should be the most important element of the constitution.[ix]
Major progress has been made in assisting the Iraqis in taking control of their country. On March 24, the Iraqi “Wolves Brigade” recaptured the Sunni-dominated southwestern portion of Mosul, from Al-Qaeda, Ansar and Baathist forces. Many prisoners were taken. This was the first time the Iraqi forces won such a significant engagement, without Coalition intervention.
Unfortunately, it appears negotiations between the EU3 (France, Germany, Britain) and Iran have reached a stalemate. Fortunately, according to the statements of public leaders, the EU3 are also onboard with prioritizing the freedom of the Iranian people as a critical component of the negotiations. This may signal a US-European effort to assist the Iranian people. However, it is unlikely that the mullahs’ rule will collapse before they have developed a nuclear weapon.
Thus, the Israelis are preparing to
stop, or at least delay, the Iranians from obtaining a nuclear
weapon.
According to
leaked information, an Israeli assault would comprise both air and
ground
operations. The Shaldag commandos are reportedly to be already
training, using
a mock uranium enrichment plant similar to the facility at Natanz. F-15
jets of
Squadron 69 using bunker buster bombs would perform the aerial assault.[x]
This summer of 2005 is going to be a
hot one. Demonstrations in Iran are going to be intense, a new
president will
be “elected” in Iran, democracy is sweeping across the region, and the
situation
with Lebanon and Syria is going to be extremely interesting. Three US
naval
carriers are heading to the Middle East. The USS Theodore Roosevelt is
moving
to the region from the Atlantic Ocean and the USS Carl Vinson is
crossing the
Indian Ocean. For the first time since February 2004, three major
carrier
groups will be in the area.[xi]
Yes, this summer is indeed going to be hot.
It does appear that the
Iranian situation will have to be
resolved with force. Despite the negotiations, and intense observation
of the
Iranians, by several governments, there is intelligence indicating that
Iran is
poised to establish a secret nuclear engineering facility, within a
year, so
they can train their own experts. And by doing this, the US and the
IAEA will
not know who they are, or how to locate them to verify operations.[xii]
Something significant must happen
regarding Iran. Whether you view the recent developments in Iran as a
humanitarian issue, a pro-democracy issue, an anti-WMD issue, or an
anti-terrorism issue – Iran is at the forefront of it all. Iranian
opposition
television has reported that, according to documents from the Fajir
Garrison of
the Iranian Revolutionary Guards, Iran has at least 40,000
agents inside
Iraq.[xiii]
Stopping Iran may be the
key to preventing a massive war
between Iran, Hezbollah and Syria, which would hurt, possibly reverse,
progress
in all Muslim countries. This is a serious concern, as highlighted by
the fact
that the Israeli General Staff foresees a major war with Syria
occurring by 2007
that involves Iran and Hezbollah.[xiv]
There were significant developments
among the Iranian opposition this month. One day after 565 dissidents
published
an open letter criticizing the mullahs, a major coalition of
expatriates formed
the Iranian Opposition Council, which includes all manner of ideologies
from
republicans to monarchists. The Council will begin activities in
mid-April.[xv]
However, according to Iranian activist sources, the Bush Administration
is not
taking this group too seriously and they likely lack popular support
inside
Iran.
Moshen Sazegara, an Iranian dissident, once imprisoned by the mullahs, is likely to make the news when Iran implodes. He has joined the calls for a national referendum on whether the Iranian constitution should be revised to make Iran a secular country, and whether unelected clerics should remain in power. Among Iranian dissidents though, it appears Sazegara isn’t too popular, as he founded the Iranian Revolutionary Guards Corps in 1979, and previously worked with Ayatollah Khomeini.
However, his joining the
Washington Institute for Near East
Policy can be a hopeful sign, as he brings attention to the referendum
cause,
and begins pushing for further investigation into Iran’s role in
overseas
assassinations, and a 1992 bombing of a Berlin restaurant. In 1997, a
German
court found that Iranian authorities had directed the bombing. Some
California-based Iranian activists are denouncing the referendum
movement,
which WorldThreats.com feels is ridiculous. Reza Pahlavi, the son of
the Shah,
overthrown by the radicals, has joined the call for the referendum as
well.[xvi]
Over to Lebanon, where up to 800,000
Lebanese protestors gathered at the grave of Rafiq Hariri, in downtown
Beirut,
to demand an end to Syrian control over their country. Keeping in mind
the fact
that Lebanon only has 3 million people, this is an impressive number.
This
equaled or exceeded the pro-Syrian demonstrations launched by Hezbollah
and
Syrian intelligence. Those demonstrations, instigated in response to
the initial
anti-Syrian demonstrations, were not as they seemed.
Syrian intelligence
forced storeowners to close during the
protests, and pressured them to head to the Mazza highway, to join the
rally.
Over a half-million Syrians, who work in Lebanon, were called upon to
participate in the demonstrations. According to some reports, thousands
of
Syrians were bussed in and Syrians attempting to leave Lebanon were
denied
passage.
Government workers and
students were threatened with losing
their jobs, or failing their classes. Add that to Hezbollah’s support
for the
demonstrations, and you have one colossal spectacle.[xvii]
And that makes it even more amazing that the Lebanese, soon after,
managed to
generate equally massive demonstrations – only entirely comprised of
Lebanese,
with no manipulations.
Bashar Assad is in his most vulnerable moment since his regime assumed power. In a development that some say means hell has frozen over, France and the US are partnering to pressure Assad into leaving Lebanon, and beginning reforms at home. President Bush has demanded that Syrian intelligence, and the army, leave Lebanon before the May elections, “or else”, which probably means UN sanctions, which would be devastating for Syria. The West should also support parliamentary elections occurring on a more local level (county) than by provinces of which there are five, as it would help diminish Syrian and Hezbollah intimidation.
Jordan’s King Abdullah has warned
American and Israeli officials that Syria is planning on using
Hezbollah to
launch terrorist attacks in Israel.[xviii]
Such an operation would distract world attention from the Lebanese
situation,
and allow Syria to argue that they’re withdrawal from Lebanon has
unleashed
chaos.
The questionable Israeli
intelligence source, Debkafile, has reported that there has been a
“complete
collapse” of the pro-Syrian political and intelligence structure in
Lebanon.
There has reportedly been an abrupt withdraw of all Syrian commands,
including
military-intelligence chief, General Ghazaleh. The Lebanese secret
service
chief, General Raymond Azar, fled to Paris, and the Internal Security
Forces
head, General Ali al-Haji, is ready to quit.[xix]
However, while
WorldThreats.com’s sources indicate there is
a less visible presence and more “free” air on the ground, another
source with
close contacts within the Lebanese opposition leaders claims Syria is
merely
reorganizing, and that “the opposite is happening”.
WorldThreats.com supports the
Lebanon and Syria Liberation Act put forth by two representatives. It
calls for
import and export sanctions on countries and companies that contribute
to
Syria’s weapons of mass destruction efforts, calls for supporting a
program for
a transition to democracy, and aiding pro-democratic and human rights
groups,
including assistance through TV and radio broadcasts.[xx]
The Palestinian areas have long been
radicalized. We’ve all seen the videos of children’s TV programs
touting the
glories of becoming a martyr, and killing Israelis. They’re taught that
Israeli
innocents and soldiers alike are synonymous targets. When asked, many
analysts
vacillated, stating that first, the propaganda would have to end for
there to
be peace, and then the radicalized people would have to die off or
become
powerless
Yet conditions have
changed, probably due to recent
elections, and developments in surrounding areas. Over the past six
months,
there has been a tremendous drop in support for suicide bombings by
Palestinians. Previously, 77% of Palestinians supported terrorist
tactics, and
now only 29% do![xxi]
If this
dramatic reversal of opinion holds, this would be a greater development
than
the elections in the Palestinian areas, and the death of Arafat.
We found a particular survey in
Saudi Arabia extremely interesting. We’re all aware of the significant
influence that Wahhabism wields there, and of the extreme radicalism
inside
Saudi society. The SAS Center in Jeddah published a poll indicating
that 87% of
the Saudis supported female voting rights in local council elections.
This runs
quite counter to what many would expect in that country.[xxii]
Europe
As noted previously, negotiations
with Iran continue, but little progress is being realized. The Iranians
have
rejected any form of economic incentives, which may have been a shrewd
move on
the part of the US, as it demonstrates that Iran is stubbornly
unwilling to
negotiate. Europe is also discussing, with the US, the situation of the
Iranian
people, and is issuing statements of moral support.
Negotiations are also
being conducted that are aimed at requiring
France and other European countries to list Hezbollah as a terrorist
organization. The French argue that they are the perfect venue to push
for
Hezbollah’s reformation into an unarmed political party. Despite these
disagreements, one can definitely argue that European-US cooperation is
quite
substantial on Iran. France and the US also stand side-by-side in
pressuring
Syria and, according to some reports, are even considering how to
undermine
Assad.
However, should Hezbollah refuse to
disarm, they cannot be tolerated indefinitely. Hezbollah leader
Nasrallah has
stated, on TV, that a European Union blacklist of his group would
“destroy”
them by drying up funding and critical sources of moral, political and
material
support. The West would do well to remember this statement, while
keeping in
mind that it may be aimed at increasing European-US tension over
Hezbollah.[xxiii]
Shady events continue to transpire in the Ukraine. The former interior minister Yuriy Kravchenko “killed himself” right before being questioned about the murder of an investigative journalist in 2000. The journalist, who died from two gunshots to the head, left a note blaming the “suicide” on the former Ukrainian government. However, it is hard to believe he killed himself by shooting his head twice, but is also equally hard to believe that, if he were murdered, apparently by government-related forces, they’d leave a suicide note pinning the death on themselves. This case is difficult to fathom, to say the least.
This was a relatively quiet month
for the continent. Intelligence sources indicate that there is evidence
of
greater collaboration between Hezbollah and Colombian rebels inside
Venezuela
and Colombia. It is reassuring to know that the Bush Administration
appears to
have an eye on Chavez, as it was leaked that the US is creating a
policy to
“contain” him.[xxiv]
Africa
UN reports are indicating that the
number of deaths in Darfur has been greatly underestimated. The sad,
depressing
news continues there, with no foreseeable improvement.
The IAEA and CIA recently “outed”
Egypt. They have disclosed that there were secret Egyptian operations
in
chemical weapons and nuclear weapons development, particularly in
plutonium and
uranium fuel cycles. There is also evidence that sophisticated chemical
weapons
technology was passed to Saddam Hussein. Over the past 20 years, Egypt
has
failed to report the use of small amounts of plutonium in 16
experiments in
creating nuclear fuel. Research took place at two research reactors at
the Inshas,
in the Nile Delta. One plant was not declared and was used for
experiments, and
design information was not submitted for a new facility currently being
built.[xxv]
Asia
The biggest development in Asia was
that the Chinese government approved a resolution authorizing the use
of
military force to stop Taiwan from declaring independence. The
Taiwanese then
launched a dramatic pro-peace demonstration, and the US called the
resolution
“unfortunate”.[xxvi]
The
Taiwanese defense minister has become particularly vocal about the
Chinese
threat, warning that the mainland will have 800 missiles aimed at the
island
next year.[xxvii]
WorldThreats.com can’t confirm the
following report, and no sources seem to know much about it.
WorldNetDaily.com
is reporting that documents in the possession of Iraqi interior
minister Falah
al-Naqib indicate a Russian and possibly Indian role in the insurgency
in Iraq.
However, no quotes and no detail are given. It simply states that
Russian
intelligence met in early January 2005 with Iranian and Indian
intelligence to
discuss how to get the US out of the region as soon as possible, or how
to at
least weaken the US position.
One of the tactics they reportedly
discussed was arming Iran with modern weaponry for use to attack US
forces in
Iraq. The memo also reportedly gives evidence that Iraq sponsored Abu
Musab
al-Zarqawi before 9-11, and that both Russia and Libya have played a
role in
helping Al-Qaeda. In a February 2005 meeting, Russia, North Korea and
Iran had
a discussion about how to reduce US influence in the region.[xxviii]
Freedom has broken loose in
Kyrgyzstan. President Askar Akayev’s government collapsed after the
opposition
stormed government offices, and the presidential compound, due to
allegations
of election fraud. The parliament has agreed to a new election, and
opposition
figure Kadyrebkov has been apponted as the interim president. Akayev
fled to
Russia, via Kazakhstan, and is currently negotiating the future of the
country’s government.
Some suspect the US had a secret
role in the events. Before parliamentary elections, an opposition paper
ran
photos of a very expensive home being built for Akayev, which caused
outrage.
The paper, it has been found, received US government grants, and
printed
through Freedom House, a printing press financed by the US.[xxix]
[i] Time, March 12, 2005.
[ii] USA Today, March 2, 2005.
[iii] Washington Post, March 24, 2005.
[iv] Associated Press, March 31, 2005.
[v] UPI, March 21, 2005.
[vi] Telegraph, March 12, 2005.
[vii] New York Times, March 12, 2005.
[viii] Reuters, March 14, 2005.
[ix] USA Today, March 15, 2005.
[x] Times Online, March 13, 2005.
[xi] India Daily, March 12, 2005.
[xii] ChannelNewsAsia.com, March 21, 2005.
[xiii] Iran Focus, February 28, 2005.
[xiv] World Tribune.com, March 10, 2005.
[xv] Regime Change Iran, March 8, 2005.
[xvi] New York Sun, March 18, 2005, Eli Lake.
[xvii] Levant News, March 23, 2005.
[xviii] WorldNetDaily.com, March 23, 2005.
[xix] Debka, March 30, 2005.
[xx] Voice of America News, March 9, 2005.
[xxi] Ha’aretz, March 14, 2005.
[xxii] Elaph.com, March 13, 2005.
[xxiii] WorldNetDaily.com, March 3, 2005.
[xxiv] Financial Times, March 13, 2005.
[xxv] MSNBC, March 15, 2005.
[xxvi] CNN.com, March 13, 2005.
[xxvii] Daily Times (Pakistan), March 11, 2005.
[xxviii] WorldNetDaily.com, March 22, 2005.
[xxix] International Herald Tribune, “West Plays Key Role in Kyrgyzstan”, March 30, 2005. Craig S. Smith.