MILNET Opinion
Our Friends, the Russians,  3/6/2005

"Entities in Russia and China are the main suppliers of NBC- and missile-related equipment and technologies, especially to states of proliferation concern.  In the last several years, Russian entities have exported ballistic missile and nuclear technology to Iran, and Russia also remians a potential source of biological and chemical warfare expertise."

- Proliferation:  Threat and Response, U.S. Department of Defense, 2001, page 3  20


We are driven to distraction by the Russians.  As my father said after Glasnost, "Just because they are talking nice, doesn't mean they are."  That makes more sense as time goes on.  They still have a huge arsenal pointed at us, they sell their weapons to all of our enemies (and to some of theirs -- how smart is that?), and then there is Putin playing Czar. 

The problems with Russia are the usual ones, they are playing the foil to the United States, they sell weapons to our enemies and so on.  Not much has really changed since the 1960s.  A budding democracy has not made them our friends, only slightly less of an enemy.  And very slightly at that.

Here is a list of gripes we have about Russia.  It is the short list.  The long list has female slavery, drugs and other assorted Russian Mafia items on board.  Russia is not unique in having a run away crime situation -- take a look at Indonesia and Malaysia.  And before the socialists get all up in arms and claim capitalism is at fault, remember greed works best in nations with dictators.  If Russia would fix the things on our list, then we'll dredge up the Russian Mafia -- first things first.

Russian Problem
Comments
Nuclear Weapons on active duty
The Russians are still the number two nuclear nation.  They are however reducing down at each milestone in START, that is commendable.  They also prove they are destroying old warheads -- the dirty secret of nuclear arms reduction is that you destroy old warheads any way -- they get very dangerous as they age.  The key is not building new ones and creating more material to build them.  It's not clear they are not doing that -- they only say they aren't. 13,14,15,16
Nuclear materials under poor security
This  remains a hot issue for many, we are not sure their security is that bad, but then again, it isn't up to the levels of European or U.S. arsenals.  Their nuclear waste security is dismal, though, and when the first dirty bomb goes off, it will be from a Russian made reactor (From Russia, Pakistan, Libya, Iran, or Iraq).  We will know because the materials are telltale.  10, 11, 19
Democratic controls being removed
Russian President is engaged in removing democratic controls slowly and apparently every month.  At this rate Putin will have nearly as much power as Andropov in about a year.  That is damned scary.  Look for a huge military budget up tick in a country that can't pay its soldiers now.  12
Support of human rights violators
Russia is the number one supplier of weapons and trades with nations that are humans rights violators on large scale.  Make a list of the humans rights violators and then look at their major trading partners, you'll find Russia.  International sanctions mean nothing to the Russians.  Oh they talk good, but it doesn't take very much investigation to disclose they lie through their teeth.  8
Opposes U.S. Policy 3/4 of the time
On nearly every issue we can think of, the Russian government has come out against it in the last ten years.  The only issue that appears to match is anti-terrorism and that is because the U.S. has capitulated on Chechnya.  Yes, there is a terrorist problem there, but it is very likely that if Russia had granted independence to Chechnya, there would be a much smaller number of terrorists active.  Having said that, there is no excuse for terrorism, so we begrudgingly allow Russia some latitude there -- note we did not place Russia's brutal treatment of Chechnya in our list, we certainly could have.
Anti-terror forces kill innocents wholesale
The use of a deadly nerve gas in the Russian theater siege demonstrates the government is clearly disinterested in the lives of individuals.  This does not bode well for the future of the Russian people.  9
The world's greatest nuclear proliferator
If they don't ship off nuclear weapons or reactor technology, they are shipping off dual use equipment that aid nuclear programs.  Iran, Libya, Pakistan, Iraq...the list is endless.  1,2,3
Iran's greatest supporter
Russian technology is everywhere in Iran, including weapons system, nuclear plants, advisors to the military, you name it.  Overall Russia sells their weapons to all of the rogue nations and dictators the world over while the rest of the world tries to apply sanctions  1,2,3
A major player in oil-for-food scandal
It goes without saying -- the skirting of sanctions against Iraq clearly tells the story whey they did not want us in Iraq -- it had nothing to do with taking out Saddam or any of the other reasons they used in the U.N. debates, it had to do with us finding the records of their complicity.  If we made a list for France, this would be at the very top, but for Russia it was an expected outcome and pretty much par for the course. 18
Helped Move Iraqi WMD to Syria
And possibly into Bekka Valley in Lebanon.  That is a frightening misjudgment by Russia.  Syria/Lebanon has been linked to terrorist training camps for the major terrorist groups -- this includes Chechen terrorists.  What were they thinking?  And now Russia is giving Syria financial credit to buy more weapons?  Opposing U.S. policy is one thing, actively aiding the number two terrorist nation? This is just crazy!   1

Thus it is no wonder that many Americans oppose continuing to play nice with Russia.  They aren't playing nice with us. If this is one of our friends, it is hard to imagine what our enemies are like.  We didn't list things like Russian duplicity in Bosnia, and the number of spec-ops guys killed trying to keep an eye on them  there.  Their support of governments engaged in horrid human rights atrocities is ghastly for a country supposedly trying to be democratic.  We simply, just do not believe it.





  1. Russia Tied to Iraq's Missing Arms, Bill Gertz, Washngton Times, 10/28/2004
  2. Russian Supply of Arms 2003, CIA Declassified Report to Congress, June 2003 (11/2004)
  3. Russain Supply of Arms 2002, CIA Declassifeid Report to Congress, June 2002 (11/2003)
  4. Russain Supply of Arms 2001, CIA Declassifeid Report to Congress, June 2001 (1/2002)
  5. Russian Duma to Consider Draft in Support of Iran, Iraq and North Korea, 2/19/2002
  6. Russia to provide fuel for Iranian Reactor, A.P., Washington Post, 3/1/2005
  7. Russian Support to Iran is a Rebuff of U.S., Daily Times (Pakistan), undated story found on 3/6/2005
  8. Russia and Chechnya Page, Human Rights Watch, various dates and various articles
  9. Report:  Russian Nerve Gas Killed Hostages, Natalia Antelava, UPI, 10/26/2002
  10. Russia Page, Russian-American Nuclear Security Advisory Council. undated
  11. Russia's Loose Nukes, James Holmes, The Washington Times, 3/3/2005
  12. The Rule of Law and the Two Faces of Vladimir Putin, The Future Of Russia.org, The National Center for Public Policy Research.
  13. A Ticking Time Bomb, Kurt Gottfried,  5/12/2003, Union of Concerned Scientists
  14. The Case for De-Alerting Nuclear Weapons, Carol Ong, 1/2001, Waging Peace.org,
  15. Russian Nuclear Policy and the Status of De-Targeting, Bruce Blair, Statement before Subcommittee on Military Research and Development, House National Security Committee, March 17, 1997
  16. U.S. and Russian Nuclear Missiles are Still on Hair-trigger Alert, Mark McDonald, Common Dreams Newscenter, 12/17/2004
  17. Oil-For-Food-Scandal Draws Scrutiny to U.N., David Asman, Fox News Online,  9/20/2004
  18. The U.N. Oil For Food Scandal, Washington Post, 3/21/2004
  19. Preventing Nuclear Terrorism, Global Security, Union of Concerned Scientists, 5/26/2004
  20. Proliferation:  Threat and Response (PDF 4.9MB), U.S. Department of Defense, 2001, page 3




© Copyright 2005, Michael Crawford for MILNET