| |
|
Patterns
of Global Terrorism
Released by the Office of the Coordinator
for Counterterrorism
May 21, 2002
Europe Overview
"The campaign to eradicate terrorism
has reached a new stage. It will be pursued on many fronts with determination
and patience. The Alliance stands ready to play its role."
Lord Robertson, Secretary-General
of NATO
8 October 2001
In the wake of the September 11 terrorist
attacks in the United States, European nations responded in dramatic fashion,
offering immediate assistance to manage the crisis and working overtime
to help build and sustain the international Coalition against terrorism.
Working together bilaterally and multilaterally, the United States and
its friends and allies in Europe demonstrated the positive impact of coordinated
action. Sustaining this close cooperation and unity of purpose will be
a strong element of a successful campaign over the long haul.
Many European countries acted quickly
to share law-enforcement and intelligence information, conduct investigations
into the attacks, and strengthen laws to aid the fight against terrorism.
The UK, France, Italy, and other European allies partnered with the US
in military operations to root out the Taliban and al-Qaida from Afghanistan.
Belgium, the holder of the six-month rotating EU presidency on September
11, immediately focused its agenda on the fight against terrorism. Spain
not only continued to weaken the Basque terrorist group, Basque Fatherland
and Liberty (ETA), but captured leaders and members of an al-Qaida cell
in Spain, and has moved to make counterterrorism a central item on the
agenda of its six-month presidency of the EU which began in January 2002.
Al-Qaida-related arrests were similarly carried out in Belgium, Bosnia,
France, Germany, Italy, and the UK.
During the year it held the rotating
presidency of the Group of Eight (G-8), Italy’s guidance of joint activities
of the Lyon Group law-enforcement experts and the Counterterrorism Experts
Group (Roma Group) resulted in substantial progress on an Action Plan for
combating terrorism. France provided outstanding political, diplomatic,
and military support to the global counterterrorism campaign. The French
have helped invigorate measures to bolster the UN’s ability to contribute
to measures against terrorism and to enhance regional counterterrorism
cooperation within Europe. Greece offered noteworthy support for the antiterrorism
Coalition. However, it remains troubling that there have been no successful
arrests and prosecutions of members of the 17 November terrorist group.
Germany’s response to the September 11 attacks was superb, with important
contributions to key diplomatic, law-enforcement, and military efforts.
German police moved swiftly to investigate leads related to the attacks,
identified al-Qaida members, made arrests, and issued warrants. Turkey
\provided invaluable logistic and basing support to the campaign in Afghanistan
as well as its full diplomatic and political support. Although Turkey’s
effective campaign against the PKK, DHKP/C, and Turkish Hizballah dealt
setbacks to those groups, they still remain capable of lethal attacks.
The European multilateral response
to the September 11 attacks through the European Union (EU) and NATO was
immediate, forceful, and unprecedented. The EU showed itself to be a strong
partner in sustaining the global Coalition and in fostering international
political cooperation against terrorism. On the day of the attacks, the
EU (under Belgium’s presidency) voiced its solidarity with the United States.
EU member states provided strong support for our efforts at the UN to adopt
strong counterterrorism resolutions and for our diplomatic efforts around
the world to get third countries to stand up against terrorism. Thereafter,
the Council of the European Union adopted an Action Plan to identify areas—such
as police and judicial cooperation, humanitarian assistance, transportation
security, and economic and finance policy—that could make a contribution
to fighting terrorism. In addition, the Council adopted a "common position,"
a framework regulation, and an implementing decision that significantly
strengthened its legal and administrative ability and that of EU member
states to take action against terrorists and their supporters—including
freezing their assets. The EU strengthened its capacity to stanch the flow
of terrorist financing by approving a regulation that enables it to freeze
terrorist assets on an EU-wide basis without waiting for a UN resolution.
The United States signed the US-Europol Agreement in December to facilitate
cooperation between our law-enforcement authorities. The EU reached agreement
on a European arrest warrant, which will greatly facilitate extradition
within member states. Under the Belgian presidency, the EU also agreed
on a regulation to freeze assets of persons and entities associated with
terrorism; the measure was approved in December by the European Parliament.
The EU also reached agreement on a common definition of terrorism and on
a common list of terrorist groups and committed to coordinated initiatives
to combat terrorism, including the intent to adopt quickly a directive
preventing money laundering in the financial system and expanding procedures
for freezing assets—to include proceeds from terrorism-related crimes.
The EU is continuing to work internally and with the US and other countries
to improve our ability to take common actions against terrorism.
For its part, NATO invoked Article
V of the NATO charter for the first time, bringing the full weight of the
organization to bear to provide for self defense against terrorism. NATO
forces have played a key role in the effort to end Afghanistan’s role as
a safehaven and in providing direct military support in securing the United
States from additional terrorist attacks.
Two of the newest NATO members, the
Czech Republic and Hungary, made immediate offers of humanitarian
and military assistance after the September 11 attacks. Amidst offers to
"backfil" American and British troops in the Balkans, the Czech Republic
deployed the 9th NBC (nuclear/biological/ chemical) company to participate
in Operation Enduring Freedom in Kuwait and loaned NATO, for its use, a
TU-154 transport plane. Hungary offered a military medical unit and is
providing antiterrorism training to other countries in the region. Both
countries pledged significant humanitarian assistance to Afghanistan at
the Tokyo donors’ conference.
The 10 Vilnius Group countries (Albania,
Bulgaria, Croatia, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Macedonia, Romania, Slovakia,
Slovenia) collectively and individually joined in condemning the September
11 attacks. These countries have actively supported the international Coalition
against terrorism, offering military and diplomatic assistance and, in
some cases, providing logistic support. They have undertaken numerous antiterrorism
measures, ranging from strengthening border security to investigating suspect
financial transactions.
In Southeastern Europe, groups of ethnic
Albanians have conducted armed attacks against government forces in southern
Serbia and Macedonia since 1999. Ethnic Albanian extremists of the so-called
National Liberation Army (NLA or UCK) launched an armed insurgency in Macedonia
in February. The NLA, which announced its disbandment in July, received
funding and weapons not only from Macedonian sources, but also from Kosovo
and elsewhere. The NLA and a group that operated in southern Serbia called
the Liberation Army of Presevo, Medvedja, and Bujanovac (PMBLA or UCPMB)
had strong ties with Kosovar political organizations, including the Popular
Movement of Kosovo and the National Movement for the Liberation of Kosovo.
Both NLA and UCPMB killed civilians and government security-force members
and harassed and detained civilians in areas they controlled. Other ethnic
Albanian extremist groups also espouse and threaten violence against state
institutions in Macedonia and the region, including the so-called Albanian
National Army (ANA or AKSH) and the National Committee for the Liberation
and Protection of Albanian Lands (KKCMTSH).
Albania
Albania continued to be an active partner
in the fight against international terrorism in the wake of September 11,
pledging "any and all assistance" to US efforts. Government and political
leaders quickly condemned the attacks. The Government also pledged NATO
access to air and seaports for units participating in Operation Enduring
Freedom, as well as commando troops. In addition, the parliamentary Assembly
called
upon all banks in Albania to locate the accounts of individuals suspected
of possessing terrorist ties and to prevent fund withdrawal or transfer.
The Albanian courts already have frozen the assets of one suspected al-Qaida
supporter. The Ministry of Finance is working to strengthen its anti-money
laundering legislation.
Various Middle Eastern-based nongovernmental
organizations (NGOs) that have been identified as supporting terrorist
activities continued to maintain a presence in Albania. Some of the NGOs
continued to provide assistance to Islamic extremists throughout the region,
to include procuring false documents and facilitating terrorist travel.
In early October, however, the Albanian Government simultaneously raided
the Tirana headquarters of four Islamic-based NGOs believed to be involved
in international Islamic extremism, detained and interrogated their principal
officers, then deported them, together with their families, into the custody
of police authorities from their home countries. From late October through
December, Albanian authorities conducted three additional raids: two on
Islamic-based NGOs suspected of supporting extremist activity, and the
third on the Tirana headquarters of an Albanian business owned by a suspected
al-Qaida supporter watchlisted by the US Department of the Treasury. The
Albanian Government detained and interrogated those organizations’ principal
officers.
Albania continues to cooperate closely
with US counterterrorism efforts on a number of levels. Grossly insufficient
border security, corruption, organized crime, and institutional weaknesses,
however, combine to make Albanian territory an attractive target for exploitation
by terrorist and Islamic extremist groups.
Belgium
Belgian Government reaction to the
tragedy of September 11 was swift and supportive. Prime Minister Verhofstadt
publicly condemned the attacks on September 11 and again on 12 September
before the European Parliament. During Belgium’s six-month term of the
rotating EU presidency in the second half of 2001, the EU made significant
progress in combating terrorism. Belgium immediately thrust counterterrorism
to the top of its agenda for EU reform efforts in the wake of the attacks.
Belgium helped to obtain key EU-wide agreement on a European arrest warrant,
which will greatly facilitate extradition within member states. As a NATO
ally, Belgium contributed a navy frigate in the Mediterranean and backfill
for Operation Enduring Freedom and provided aircraft for humanitarian assistance
to Afghanistan.
The Belgians cooperated on many levels
with US counterterrorism efforts, from information sharing to policymaking.
Belgian authorities arrested on 13 September Tunisian national, Nizar Trabelsi
and Moroccan Tabdelkrim El Hadouti, (brother of Said El Hadouti who was
charged in Morocco with helping to provide false documents to the Massoud
suicide bombers) for involvement in an alleged plot against the
US Embassy in Paris. Police also seized from Trabelsi’s apartment a submachinegun,
ammunition, and chemical formulas for making explosive devices.
Terrorists, however, have found it
relatively easy to exploit Belgium’s liberal asylum laws, open land borders,
and investigative, prosecutorial, or procedural weaknesses in order to
use the country as an operational staging area for international terrorist
attacks. The forgery of Belgian passports and theft of Belgian passports
from Belgian Government offices have facilitated terrorists’ ability to
travel. For example, the two suicide-assassins of Northern Alliance leader
Ahmad Shah Massoud in Afghanistan on 9 September had traveled as journalists
under false names on Belgian passports stolen from consulates in France
and the Netherlands. The Belgian Government instituted a new passport with
state-of-the-art anti-fraud features in March 2001.
In December, Belgian authorities arrested
Tarek Maaroufi, a Tunisian-born Belgian national, on charges of involvement
in trafficking of forged Belgian passports. Maaroufi was charged with forgery,
criminal association, and recruiting for a foreign army or armed force.
Belgian authorities suspect the forged passports are linked to those used
by the two suicide-assassins of Northern Alliance leader Massoud. Italian
authorities also sought Maaroufi for his ties to known al-Qaida cells.
Belgian authorities also opened an investigation into the activities of
Richard Reid, the accused "shoe bomber" who on 2 December was overpowered
on board American Airlines Flight 63. Reid stayed at a hotel in Brussels
from 5-16 December and frequented local cybercafes.
Belgium is beginning to add legislative
and judicial tools that will increase its ability to respond to terrorist
threats. The Belgian Government assisted in the investigation of several
cases of international terrorism, both among European states and with the
United States. Belgian cabinet ministers agreed in November on a draft
bill aimed at facilitating wiretaps, the use of informants, and other expanded
investigative techniques.
Belgium fully implemented all UNSC
resolutions requiring freezing of Taliban-related assets.
Bosnia and Herzegovina
After September 11, Bosnian Government
authorities pledged to put all possible resources toward the fight against
international terrorism. As Bosnia has been a transit point for Islamic
extremists, the State border service enacted a variety of measures to control
the borders more effectively, including the introduction of a new landing-card
document travelers are required to complete upon arrival at the airport.
Following the attacks on September
11, Ministry of the Interior authorities arrested several individuals suspected
of involvement in terrorist activity, including an associate of Bin Ladin
lieutenant Abu Zubaydah and five Algerian nationals suspected of being
Algerian Armed Islamic Group (GIA) operatives; Sabir Lahmar, one of the
detained GIA operatives, had made threats against SFOR and US interests
in the past.
Even before the September 11 attacks,
the Bosnian Government was engaged actively in measures to combat terrorism.
In April, authorities arrested Sa’id Atmani, a suspected GIA associate
who roomed with Ahmed Ressam while he was in Canada, and extradited him
to France in July, where he was wanted on an INTERPOL warrant. In July,
Bosnian Government authorities arrested two members of the Egyptian group
al-Gama’a al-Islamiyya—Imad al-Misri and al-Sharif Hassan Sa’ad. Both men
were extradited to Egypt in October.
Various NGOs that have been identified
as supporting terrorist activities, however, maintained a presence in Bosnia.
The NGOs, which came to the region during the 1992-1995 Bosnian war, continued
to provide assistance to Islamic extremists throughout Bosnia, to include
procuring false documents and facilitating terrorist travel. The Government
has taken some significant steps to freeze assets and monitor activities
of some of the NGOs, but their ability to carry out efforts to combat these
organizations has been weakened by some residual support for those in the
Islamic world that supported Bosnia wartime efforts.
Following September 11, Bosnian banking
authorities have worked diligently to identify and freeze suspected terrorist
assets in the financial sector.
France
France has provided substantial diplomatic,
political, and other support to the war against terrorism. French officials
expressed their determination to eradicate the "perverse illness" of terrorism
and offered military and logistics contributions. Following the attacks
on the United States, France played an important role in crafting a UN
response to terrorism and joined other NATO allies in invoking Article
5, the mutual-defense clause of the NATO treaty. Paris quickly granted
three-month blanket overflight clearances for US aircraft and offered air,
naval, and ground assets that were integrated into Operation Enduring Freedom.
At year’s end, the French had also committed ground troops as part of the
international peacekeeping force in Afghanistan.
During
2001, French law-enforcement officers tracked, arrested, and prosecuted
individuals who they suspected had ties to al-Qaida and other extremist
groups. In April, a Paris court sentenced Fateh Kamel to eight years in
prison for running an underground terrorist logistics network linked to
al-Qaida. French authorities established clear links between Kamel and
Ahmed Ressam, who had plotted to attack the Los Angeles Airport in December
1999. On 10 September, a French magistrate opened a formal investigation
into an alleged plot by an al-Qaida-linked group to target US interests
in France and placed its alleged ringleader, Djamel Beghal, who was extradited
from the United Arab Emirates on 1 October, in investigative detention.
In November, the French Parliament
passed the "everyday security" bill, which allows for expanded police searches
and telephone and Internet monitoring, along with enhanced measures to
disrupt terrorist finances. Finance Minister Fabius responded rapidly to
US requests related to Executive Order 13224 to freeze Taliban and al-Qaida
finances. As of December, France had frozen $4 million in Taliban assets.
Fabius also established a new interagency unit, designated FINTER, to provide
a focal point within the Ministry for efforts to block the financing of
terrorism. On an international level, the French were among the principal
advocates for creating the UN Security Council’s counterterrorism committee,
and they cooperated with US officials in G-8 counterterrorism meetings.
Regionally, Paris continued working
with Madrid to crack down on the terrorist group Basque Fatherland and
Liberty (ETA). In late 2001, the number of confrontations between French
officers and the Basque group increased notably, resulting in the wounding
of several policemen. French authorities also discovered that major ETA
training activities were taking place within France. In an unprecedented
decision in September, French magistrates refused residency to 17 Spanish
Basque residents who had links to ETA and gave them one month to leave
French territory. Moreover, French officials arrested several ETA members
in September, including Asier Oyarzabal, the suspected head of ETA’s logistics
apparatus.
Pro-independence Corsican groups continued
to attack Government offices on the island. The murder of nationalist leader
Francois Santoni in August and the ongoing debate with the mainland over
the island’s autonomy heightened tensions and increased the threat of continued
violence. French officers arrested Rene Agonstini in September for complicity
in murder and kidnapping.
Germany
Immediately following the September
11 attacks, Chancellor Schroeder pledged "unreserved solidarity" with the
United States, initiated a sweeping criminal investigation in close cooperation
with US law enforcement, and moved to prepare the German public and his
Government to adopt antiterrorism legislation that included closing legal
loopholes and increasing the monitoring of suspected terrorist groups.
On 16 November the Bundestag approved
German military participation in Operation Enduring Freedom (OEF). German
soldiers are currently serving in OEF and the International Security Assistance
Force in Afghanistan, and Germany has taken a leading role in efforts to
train and equip a new Afghan police force.
Soon
after the attack, German police conducted raids on several apartments in
Hamburg where the September 11 hijackers and associates once resided. Numerous
law-enforcement actions followed.
On 10 October, German police arrested
a Libyan, Lased Ben Henin, near his Munich home in coordinated raids that
also included the arrest of two Tunisians in Italy. Ben Hanin is suspected
of links to al-Qaida’s terrorist network and was extradited to Italy on
23 November.
On 18 October, German authorities issued
an international arrest warrant for Zakariya Essabar, Said Bahaji, and
Ramzi Omar who allegedly belonged to a Hamburg terrorist cell that included
three of the September 11 hijackers.
On 28 November, German police arrested
Mounir El Motassadeq, a 27-year old Moroccan, at his Hamburg apartment
on charges he controlled an account used to bankroll several of the September
11 hijackers and had "intensive contacts" with the terrorist cell. The
Federal Prosecutor's Office stated that El Motassadeq had close contact
over a period of years with several members of the Hamburg cell, including
the suspected ringleader, Mohamed Atta. He had power of attorney over hijacker
Marwan al-Shehhi's bank account, according to the statement.
On 12 December, Germany banned a network
of radical Islamic groups centered on the Cologne-based Kaplan organization.
Police conducted 200 house searches in seven different German states in
connection with the ban and seized the headquarters of the Kaplan group,
which authorities had previously characterized as antidemocratic and anti-Semitic.
The ban also covers the Kaplan-associated foundation, "Servants of Islam"
and 19 other subsidiary groups with a total of approximately 1,100 members.
The leader of the group, Metin Kaplan, who is serving a jail term for calling
for the murder of a rival religious leader, is widely known in Germany
as the "Caliph of Cologne."
Germany increased funding for the security
services by some $1.5 billion and announced the creation of 2,320 new positions
in various agencies to combat terrorism. Government authorities are using
advanced technology to uncover potential terrorists, including so-called
"sleepers" and terrorist-support personnel in Germany.
After four years of testimony and deliberations,
a German court convicted four of five suspects in the 1986 bombing of the
Labelle Discotheque in Berlin, in which two US servicemen died. One defendant
was convicted of murder while three others were convicted as accessories
to murder and sentenced to prison terms of 12-14 years each. A fifth suspect
was acquitted for lack of evidence. The court's verdict also made clear
Libyan Government involvement in planning and facilitating the attack.
The prosecution has appealed the verdict to seek longer sentences, while
the defense has appealed as well; the appeal process could take up to two
years.
Greece
The Greek Government, after September
11, joined its EU partners in setting up interdiction mechanisms in support
of the war on terrorism, to include greater security at points of entry,
information sharing with the United States and its Coalition allies, and
the monitoring of suspected terrorist financial assets. The Greek
Parliament took meaningful steps toward demonstrating its commitment to
combating terrorism by passing a comprehensive anti-organized-crime-and
terrorism bill. Among its key provisions, the legislation mandates magistrate
trials (eliminating citizen jurors, who have in the past been vulnerable
to personal threats), sanctions police undercover operations, authorizes
the use of DNA as court evidence, and permits electronic surveillance beyond
traditional wiretaps.
Greek and US authorities maintained
good cooperation investigating past terrorist attacks on US citizens. Nevertheless,
the Greek Government has not yet arrested or convicted those terrorists
responsible for attacks conducted by Revolutionary Organization 17 November
(17N) or Revolutionary Nuclei (RN) over the past two decades.
A series of court rulings that effectively
reduced the sentences of suspected Greek terrorists or overturned guilty
verdicts in high-profile terrorist-related cases represented a setback
on one counterterrorism front.
Anti-State Struggle terrorist and longtime
criminal fugitive Avraam Lesperoglou had been found guilty of several charges,
including involvement in the attempted murder of a Greek police officer,
for which he received a 17-year sentence. In April, the verdict was overturned
on appeal. By October, charges regarding Lesperoglou’s association with
Anti-State Struggle similarly were dropped after prosecution witnesses
failed to appear in court or recanted previous testimony identifying him
at the scene of the crime. Following these developments, there were allegations
of witness intimidation. In November, Lesperoglou was cleared of all charges
and set free.
In another prominent case, self-confessed
Urban Anarchist guerrilla Nikos Maziotis had his 15-year sentence reduced
to fewer than 5 years. Afterwards, the trial judge ruled that he agreed
with the unrepentant Maziotis’ contention that "the placement of an explosive
device at a Greek Government ministry was a political statement and not
an act of terrorism."
The courts imposed only token penalties
on a young woman caught in the act of placing a gas-canister bomb in front
of the US Consulate General in Thessaloniki in 1999 and delayed until 2003
a prosecutor's request to retry the case.
Anti-US terrorist attacks in Greece
declined significantly from a high of 20 in 1999 to only three in 2001.
Greece’s most lethal terrorist group, Revolutionary Organization 17 November
did not claim any attacks in 2001, nor did Greece’s other prominent terrorist
group, Revolutionary Nuclei. Anarchist groups appeared more active in employing
terrorist tactics, however, seizing upon antiglobalization and antiwar
themes. The three low-level incendiary attacks on US interests in Greece
in 2001 consisted of one unclaimed attack against a US fast-food chain
and two others against US-plated vehicles by the group Black Star. Other
lesser-known groups attacked numerous domestic targets while the "Revolutionary
Violence Group" attacked Thai and Israeli official interests.
Greek officials began planning for
security for the 2004 Summer Olympic Games in Athens and continued to work
with key countries having extensive security and/or Olympics experience
through a series of consultative conferences and symposiums, to include
several meetings of the seven-nation Olympic Security Advisory Group— Australia,
France, Germany, Israel, Spain, United Kingdom, and United States.
Italy
Italy stepped up its counterterrorism
efforts following the September 11 attacks and has vigorously supported
the United States diplomatically and politically. Taking a prominent role
in the international Coalition against al-Qaida, Italy declared its support
for the US-led war and offered to contribute military forces, including
naval, air and ground units. Italy also enhanced its law-enforcement capabilities,
recently passing a series of antiterrorism laws enumerating new criminal
offenses for terrorist acts and providing new and expanded police powers.
| Italy: A Terrorist Cell Wrapped Up
Italy has a long history of combating domestic and
international terrorism. Through its exceptional law enforcement agencies
and newly enhanced judiciary powers, Italy has dismantled numerous terrorist
cells, identified and frozen assets belonging to terrorist groups, and
thwarted several planned and potential attacks against Italian targets
and other Western entities within its borders.
In January, Italian authorities worked with US officials
to thwart an attack on the US Embassy in Rome. Italy’s intelligence services
launched an investigation that resulted in the US Embassies in Rome and
the Vatican City, as well as the US Consulates in Naples and Milan, being
closed to the public—the first such security closure of the Embassy in
Rome since the Gulf war in 1991. Italy’s prompt action, combined with heightened
defenses put into place by police authorities, allowed the Embassy to reopen
while the Italians pursued the investigation.
Information developed by Italian authorities helped
to identify Tarek Maaroufi as a suspect, as well as two organizations already
under investigation, the "Tunisian Combatant Group" and the "Salafist Group
for Call and Combat " (GSPC). The Italian Government is seeking Maaroufi’s
extradition from Belgium.
Authorities learned that Sami Ben Khemais Essid, who
spent two years in Afghanistan and trained as a recruiter for al-Qaida,
directed the plot. They believe Ben Khemais headed al-Qaida operations
in Italy. He owned a firm that was a front for his recruitment activity
and terrorist-attack planning.
During surveillance of Ben Khemais Essid, police discovered
he maintained connections to militant
terrorist cells throughout Europe. According to investigators,
the terrorists attended the Islamic Cultural Institute in Milan–a location
that was under surveillance months before September 11 by Italian authorities
seeking evidence of arms, chemicals, and explosives. Others who frequented
the Islamic Cultural Institute included terrorists associated with the
1993 bombing of the World Trade Center and the 1998 bombings of the US
Embassies in Tanzania and Kenya, all of which were perpetrated by al-Qaida.
Ben
Khemais was arrested, convicted, and recently sentenced to eight years
in prison. By April, five North Africans with links to Usama Bin Ladin
were in custody in connection with the terrorist plot against the US Embassy.
In October, additional arrest warrants were issued following information
obtained by police and judicial authorities confirming a "significant"
link between al-Qaida and those arrested.
According to an Italian press report, authorities also
obtained evidence to suggest that the terrorist cell was contemplating
using poison gas. On 14 March 2001, Italian police recorded a conversation
in which Ben Khemais said, "The product is better. It’s more efficient
because this liquid, as soon as you open it, it suffocates people."
Another potential plot was foiled when individuals
reportedly associated with Bin Ladin terrorists allegedly plotted to assassinate
President George W. Bush during the G-8 meeting in Genoa, Italy, in July.
The threat was taken seriously, but with tightened security for the summit,
the danger was averted.
Following the attacks of September, Italian President
Carlo Azeglio Ciampi emphasized his country’s solidarity with the United
States in the fight against terrorism. Similarly, Prime Minister Silvio
Berlusconi emphasized that "Italy is today at the United States' side,
it always will be, as it has been in the past." Acting on its own accord,
the Italian Government accelerated the procedures necessary to allow for
US forces to conduct Operation Enduring Freedom flights from the Sigonella
Air Base in Sicily. Sigonella became the most active air base in Europe
for US military flights in transit to southwest Asia.
"The measures that Italy adopted are an integral part
of the same strategy that also must be followed at the international level,"
Italian Interior Minister Claudio Scajola said during a news conference
with US Attorney General Ashcroft on 15 December . "We have also decided
to further intensify our working relationship on security measures, by
reactivating the US-Italy Bilateral Committee in order to ensure an even
more effective exchange of information between our two countries."
Italy played a prominent role in Operation Enduring
Freedom by deploying the fourth largest force, including the aircraft carrier
Garibaldi, over 2,500 military personnel, eight Harrier jets, and six Tornado
reconnaissance aircraft. Italy also supplied two frigates and a supply
ship to the Gulf. Separately, approximately 350 Italian soldiers have been
assigned to the International Afghan Security Force for Afghanistan–whose
mission is to assist in the stabilization of Kabul.
On both the law enforcement and legislative fronts,
Italy has established a sophisticated system to thwart acts of terrorism.
Furthermore, in response to the September 11 attacks, Italian authorities
responded quickly and aggressively to US Embassy-Rome’s requests for additional
support and protection. The Italian Government, in an evident display of
its commitment to the war on terrorism, passed in October a decree providing
additional powers to the police and judiciary to investigate and pursue
suspected terrorists. The Parliament supported the Government’s action
and passed the decree into law in December. The law also has enabled the
Italian Government to act quickly on freezing assets of terrorist groups.
On 7 November, the Italian Parliament approved sending
ground troops, air units, and naval units to assist in the operations against
international terrorism. According to Italian authorities, more than 90%
of the Parliament supported these counterterrorism measures and, according
to then-Foreign Minister Ruggiero, these actions confirmed Italy’s "awareness
that the stakes are high and proves the solidity of our national consensus
in facing this challenge."
According to Italian Minister Claudio Scajola, "Italy
has known of terrorism in ways that the United States has never experienced,
and we need to learn as much as we can from experiences that each nation
has had, that we can use as a basis for cooperation with each other." |
In the weeks following the attacks,
Italian law-enforcement officials intensified their efforts to track and
arrest individuals they suspect have ties to al-Qaida and other extremist
groups. On 10 October they arrested several extremists connected to Essid
Sami Ben Khemais—the Tunisian Combatant Group leader arrested by the Italians
in April for plotting to bomb the US Embassy in Rome. In mid- and late
November, Italian officials raided the Islamic Cultural Institute in Milan
and arrested Islamic extremists having possible ties to al-Qaida (see case
study following this section). Italy also cooperated in stemming the flow
of finances linked to terrorism. The Financial Security Committee, comprising
senior officials of various ministries, including Finance, Foreign Affairs,
and Justice, and representatives from law-enforcement agencies, was created
in October to identify and block the funding of terrorist activity.
During
the year Italy also concentrated on dismantling not only indigenous terrorist
groups that in the past attacked Italian and US interests, but also groups
suspected of international terrorist affiliations operating within and
outside Italy’s borders. In April, the Revolutionary Proletarian Initiative
Nuclei (NIPR) bombed the Institute of International Affairs in Rome. The
Anti-Imperialist Territorial Nuclei (NTA) claimed to have attacked the
tribunal courthouse building in Venice in August and the Central European
Initiative (INCE) office in Trieste in September 2000. Both groups are
leftist-anarchist entities that promote anti-US/anti-NATO rhetoric and
espouse the ideals of the Red Brigades of the 1970s and 1980s.
Italy’s vigorous leadership of the
Group of Eight (G-8) Counterterrorism Expert’s Group resulted in significant
progress on a 25-point plan to guide the G-8’s contribution to the global
counterterrorism campaign. The Action Plan has fostered greater counterterrorism
coordination among the foreign affairs and law-enforcement agencies of
G-8 members. Italy’s work with other European countries to combat terrorism
as well as extensive cooperation among Italy, the United States, and several
European countries—including Spain, France, Germany, Britain, and Belgium—led
to the arrests on 10 October. Moreover, Rome worked with Madrid to improve
bilateral efforts against terrorism, agreeing in early November at a summit
in Granada to create a joint investigative team to fight terrorism and
conduct joint patrols on long-distance trains to prevent illegal immigration.
Poland
Stressing solidarity as a NATO ally,
Poland has taken a leadership role in expanding counterterrorism cooperation
with key regional and international partners. In November, President Kwasniewski
hosted the Warsaw Conference on Combating Terrorism. The Conference resulted
in an action plan and a declaration that identified areas for regional
cooperation and called for nations in the region to enhance their abilities
to contribute to the global war on terrorism. Poland strongly supported
the campaign against the Taliban and al-Qaida in Afghanistan, and the US
Central Command has accepted Poland’s offer of specialized units. The Government
of Poland has also taken significant steps to bolster its own internal
capabilities to combat terrorist activities and the movement of terrorist
funds. Poland’s excellent border controls, high level of airport security,
and its close cooperation on law-enforcement issues have discouraged potential
terrorist movements through Poland.
Spain
The September 11 attacks in the United
States triggered unqualified support from Madrid in the global fight against
terrorism. Spain, which has waged a 30-year battle against the Basque Fatherland
and Liberty (ETA) terrorist group, champions mutual assistance as a strategy
to deny safehaven to terrorists and welcomes the global focus to help defeat
all forms of terrorism. Immediately after the attacks, President Aznar
announced that his Government will stand "shoulder to shoulder" with the
United States in fighting terrorism; he has directed all relevant agencies
to work closely with US law-enforcement counterparts. Spanish police broke
up two al-Qaida-affiliated cells, arresting six members in late September
and eight in November. Spain also offered military aid to Coalition efforts
in Afghanistan. Madrid plans to use its leadership of the European Union—in
the first half of 2002—to promote continued EU support for counterterrorism
cooperation.
During his trip to Spain in June, President
Bush declared that the United States stands "side by side with the government
of Spain and will not yield in the face of terrorism."
Madrid’s
top counterterrorism priority beyond supporting the global Coalition against
terrorism remained combating ETA, which maintained its violent strategy
throughout 2001, despite a Basque regional election that demonstrated diminishing
popular support for the group’s political wing. The group made good on
its threats to target Spain’s tourist areas during its summer campaign
with a series of attacks that caused mainly property damage: a car bomb
at Madrid’s Barajas International Airport damaged scores of cars, while
a bomb attack at a popular tourist resort near Barcelona slightly injured
about 10 persons. It also continued to attack traditional targets—politicians,
military personnel, journalists, and police. A bomb in Catalonia in March
killed one police officer, while another bomb in Madrid in June fatally
injured a Spanish general. An ETA commando headquartered in the Basque
region is suspected of killing a Basque police officer in July. According
to official Spanish Government data, ETA terrorists killed 15 persons in
2001, most of whom were members of either the military or security services.
Madrid scored a variety of successes
against ETA during the year, dismantling a dozen important terrorist cells
and disrupting some of the group’s logistics bases. In October, the Spanish
National Police dismantled an ETA cell in the Basque region that, in addition
to organizing smaller commando cells, was planning to launch attacks. Two
of those arrested were linked to the assassination of a senior Basque Socialist
politician in February 2000. Spanish police in early December arrested
several members of a cell suspected in several car bombings during the
year, including the attack at Madrid’s airport. They confiscated more than
100 pounds of explosives and a variety of false documentation.
Spain continued to forge bilateral
agreements with states that can help it defeat ETA terrorism. In January,
Madrid signed a joint political declaration with the United States, which
included an explicit commitment to work jointly against ETA. Spain also
concluded important agreements with France and Mexico, two key partners
in the effort to deny potential sanctuaries to ETA members. During his
visit to Mexico in July, President Aznar signed an agreement with Mexico
that boosted intelligence sharing, security, and judicial cooperation on
terrorism. In early October, Paris and Madrid signed a new bilateral agreement
that eases extraditions of ETA suspects and improves antiterrorism cooperation.
Under the agreement, a former ETA leader—charged in an attempted assassination
of King Juan Carlos in 1995—was temporarily extradited to Spain to stand
trial. Following his trial, he will be returned to France to complete a
10-year sentence there before being sent back to Spain to serve any additional
time meted out by the Spanish court.
Turkey
The Turkish Government, long a staunch
counterterrorism ally, fully supported the campaign against terrorism.
Turkey provided basing and overflight rights and has sent troops to Afghanistan
to train the local military and participate in the International Security
Assistance Force. At home, Turkish security authorities dealt heavy blows
to the country’s two most active terrorist organizations, the DHKP/C and
Turkish Hizballah—a Kurdish Islamic (Sunni) extremist organization unrelated
to Lebanese Hizballah. Police arrested more than 100 members and supporters
of the DHKP/C and several hundred members and supporters of Turkish Hizballah
and raided numerous safe houses, recovering large caches of weapons, computers
and other technical equipment, and miscellaneous documents.
Despite these setbacks, the DHKP/C
retained a lethal capability and, for the first time in its history, conducted
suicide bombings. On 3 January, a DHPK/C operative walked into a police
regional headquarters in Istanbul and detonated a bomb strapped to his
body, killing himself and a policeman, and injuring seven others. A second
DHKP/C suicide bomber attacked a police booth in a public square in Istanbul
on 10 September, killing two policemen, mortally wounding an Australian
tourist, and injuring more than 20.
Turkish Hizballah conducted its first
attack against official Turkish interests with the assassination on 24
January of Diyarbakir Police Chief Gaffar Okkan and five policemen—revealing
a greater sophistication than the group had shown in previous attacks.
According to press reports, four teams consisting of as many as 20 operatives
ambushed Okkan’s motorcade as he departed the Diyarbakir Governor’s office.
Authorities recovered approximately 460 bullet casings at the scene. Hizballah
operatives also ambushed three police officers in Istanbul on 14 October,
killing two and wounding the other.
Chechen separatists and sympathizers
also used Turkey as a staging ground for terrorist attacks. On 22 April,
13 pro-Chechen gunmen—led by Muhammed Tokcan, an ethnic-Chechen Turkish
national who served fewer than four years in prison for hijacking a Russian
ferry from Turkey in 1996—took over a prominent Istanbul hotel, holding
hostage for 12 hours approximately 150 guests, including 37 US citizens.
The gunmen, who eventually surrendered peacefully, claimed that they wanted
to focus world attention on Russia’s activities in Chechnya. Turkey’s court
system has been relatively lenient with pro-Chechen terrorists. The state
court addressing the hotel incident did not indict Tokcan’s group under
the country’s stringent antiterrorism laws but instead charged the militants
with less serious crimes, including weapons possession and deprivation
of liberty.
Separately, three Chechens hijacked
a Russian charter jet carrying 175 passengers, mostly Russian nationals,
from Istanbul to Moscow on 15 March. Fuel limitations forced the plane
to land in Medina, Saudi Arabia. Saudi authorities negotiated with the
hijackers overnight before special forces stormed the plane and captured
two of the separatists. The third hijacker, one crewmember, and one passenger
were killed during the rescue.
The PKK continued to pursue its "peace
initiative"—launched by imprisoned PKK Chairman Abdullah Ocalan in August
1999—concentrating largely on its public relations efforts in Western Europe.
The leadership announced early in the year the inauguration of a second
phase of its peace initiative, called serhildan (uprising)—the term
usually connotes violent activity, but the PKK uses it to refer to civil
disobedience—in which PKK members in Europe openly declare their identity
as Kurds and their involvement in the group, sign petitions, and hold demonstrations
in an effort to push for improved rights for the Kurdish minority in Turkey.
The PKK began conducting serhildan activities in Turkey toward the
end of the year; authorities arrested some PKK members who participated.
United Kingdom
The United Kingdom has been Washington’s
closest partner in the post-September 11 international Coalition against
terrorism. The UK stepped forward to share the military burden of the battle
against al-Qaida and the Taliban in Afghanistan. More than 4,000 British
personnel were assigned to Operation Veritas, the UK contribution to the
US-led Operation Enduring Freedom, which began on 7 October. Significant
UK naval, air, ground, and special forces participated in operations against
the Taliban and al-Qaida. London is leading the International Security
Assistance Force to help the new Afghan Interim Authority provide security
and stability in Kabul.
At
home, the British detained 10 individuals with suspected foreign terrorist
links and intensified surveillance of other individuals based on information
indicating links to terrorist activities. At year’s end, the UK had detained
and was assisting in extraditing to the US four individuals charged with
terrorist acts in the United States or against US citizens. Consistent
with the UK’s Terrorism Act of 2000, which widened the definition of terrorism
to include international as well as domestic activities, the Government
in February 2001 added 21 international terrorist organizations—including
al-Qaida—to its list of proscribed organizations. Parliament in mid-December
passed the Anti-Terrorism, Security, and Crime Act, providing authorities
with additional tools in the battle against terrorism. The new legislation
gives the Government legal authority to detain for six-month renewable
terms foreign terrorist suspects who cannot be deported under UK law. It
also provides for tightened airport security, allows security services
full access to lists of air and ferry passengers, tightens asylum rules,
and criminalizes the act of assisting foreign groups to acquire weapons
of mass destruction.
The United Kingdom has been working
with the United States and the UN to disrupt the cash supply of suspected
terrorist groups. As of late 2001, UK authorities had frozen more than
70 million pounds ($100,000,000) of suspected terrorist assets. A proposed
antiterrorism bill would require financial institutions to report suspicious
transactions or face legal penalties.
In ongoing efforts to end domestic
terrorism, the UK and other parties to the Northern Ireland peace process
made progress toward fulfilling terms of the Good Friday Agreement. In
October, the Irish Republican Army (IRA) put an undisclosed amount of weapons
and ammunition "beyond use." Dissident Republican splinter groups—the Real
IRA (RIRA) and the Continuity IRA (CIRA)—denounced the move, and called
on disgruntled IRA members to join RIRA and CIRA. Statistics indicated
that the number of terrorist killings in the North remained consistent,
with 18 deaths in 2000 and 17 in 2001. UK authorities believe that RIRA
is responsible for an intensified bombing campaign during the year on the
mainland, with bombs exploding outside the BBC’s London headquarters (March);
in North London (April); in West London (August); and in Birmingham (November).
Moreover, the year saw an upswing in Loyalist paramilitary violence, primarily
in the form of pipe-bomb attacks on Catholic homes in North Belfast. In
addition, for 12 weeks during the autumn, Protestants residing near a Catholic
school in North Belfast held highly publicized protests that were sometimes
marred by violence.
The United States continued to lend
support to the Northern Ireland peace process, with President Bush stating
in March that Washington stands ready to help London and Dublin "…in any
way the governments would find useful." In March, the USG designated the
RIRA as a Foreign Terrorist Organizations; and following September 11,
the US Government included CIRA, the Orange Volunteers and the Red Hand
Defenders on the Terrorist Exclusion List (TEL)—a move that means their
members are barred from entering the United States. Later in the year,
the Government of Colombia detained three individuals with IRA links based
on suspicion they had been training rebels from the Revolutionary Armed
Forces of Colombia (FARC), a Marxist guerrilla group involved in drugs
and on the US list of Foreign Terrorist Organizations. US officials made
clear Washington’s displeasure about possible IRA/FARC connections, stating
that the United States will have no tolerance for any ongoing or future
cooperation between these organizations.
Yugoslavia/Kosovo
The Government of the Federal Republic
of Yugoslavia announced its support for international efforts to combat
terrorism immediately after the September 11 attacks. Belgrade, already
a party to six of the UN antiterrorism conventions, by year’s end signed
the convention on funding of terrorism and reportedly intended to sign
four more in the near future. In addition, the Government of Yugoslavia
planned to take steps to implement financial sanctions against groups involved
in terrorist-related activity. Yugoslav officials arrested and detained
several suspect Arabs in November and December, including 32 Afghanis transiting
Serbia in late October.
The UN and NATO, the international
civil and security presence exercising authority in Kosovo, have firmly
supported international efforts to combat terrorism. The UN promulgated
new regulations that will make it easier to identify and apprehend suspected
terrorists and has worked to improve Kosovo’s border security. NATO has
increased its own border-interdiction efforts and its monitoring of organizations
with potential links to terrorism. Kosovar political leaders expressed
their strong support for the fight against global terrorism.
Various NGOs identified as supporting
terrorist activities maintained a presence in Kosovo. The NGOs, largely
staffed by a small number of foreign Islamic extremists and a few dozen
local radicals, do not enjoy wide support among Kosovo’s moderate Muslim
population. In December, NATO Troops conducted raids against the Global
Relief Foundation, an NGO in Kosovo with alleged links to terrorist organizations.
|